HRPaV\[,', C\aVPR \S B RRaV[T `' L _VaaR[[\aVPR \S RNPU Z RRaV[T \S aur Z RZ OR_` `UNYYOR T VcR[ Of% \_ Na aur QV_RPaV\[\S% aur `RP_RaN_f \_ ]R_`\[Nb

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "HRPaV\[,', C\aVPR \S B RRaV[T `' L _VaaR[[\aVPR \S RNPU Z RRaV[T \S aur Z RZ OR_` `UNYYOR T VcR[ Of% \_ Na aur QV_RPaV\[\S% aur `RP_RaN_f \_ ]R_`\[Nb"

Jemima Palmer
5 years ago
Views:

1 5 B 9C898 5 C8 G9HI5 I98 6M&A5 L H D; 9A@ =DGCA5 C8>C< 7DB B J C>IM5 HHD7>5 I>DC% >C7'!/1)#*% ) 7,!+%!,$ *-#!1)-, HRPaV\[ *'* IUR [NZ R \S auv` P\_]\_NaV\[ V` 9A@ =DGC A5 C8>C< 7DB B JC>IM 5 HHD7>5 I>DC% >C7'% N[Q UR_RV[NSaR_Va`UNYYOR `\Z RaVZ R` _RSR RQ a\ N` aur i5 ``\PVNaV\['j HRPaV\[*'+ IUR 5 ``\PVNaV\[`UNYYUNcR Va` ]_V[PV]NY\SSVPR V[=\d N_Q 7\b [af% B N_fYN[Q% \_`b PU \aur_ Y\PNaV\[ d VaUV[ aur HaNaR \S B N_fYN[Q N` aur 6\N_Q \S 8V_RPa\_` #UR_RV[ i6\n_qj$ Z Nf QR`VT [NaR' HRPaV\[*', B RRaV[T ` \S Z RZ OR_` N[Q QV_RPa\_` Z Nf OR URYQ V[7\Yb Z OVN% B N_fYN[Q% \_Na `b PU \aur_`b VaNOYR ]YNPR d VaUV[aUR HaNaR \S B N_fYN[Q% d UVPU V` P\[cR[VR[a a\ aur Z RZ OR_`UV]% N` aur 6\N_Q Z Nf QR`VT [NaR'!/1)#*% )) 7 01!1%$.2/.-0% HRPaV\[+'* =R_Ra\S\_R% 9YX U\_[AN[QV[T 7\Z Z b [Vaf 5 ``\PVNaV\[% >[P' d N` Qb Yf V[P\_]\_NaRQ N` N[\[&]_\SVa P\_]\_NaV\[\S aur HaNaR \S B N_fYN[Q d VaU aur 5 _avpyr` \S >[P\_]\_NaV\[SVYRQ S\_ ]b OYVP _RP\_Q V[aUR \SSVPR \SaUR 8R]N_aZ R[a\S5 ``R``Z R[a` N[Q INeNaV\[\S`NVQ `anar' HRPaV\[ +'+ =\d N_Q =\Z R` 8RcRY\]Z R[a 7\_]' N[Q Dd R[ 6_\d [ INa`SVRYQ 8RcRY\]Z R[a 7\Z ]N[f% RNPU N B N_fYN[Q P\_]\_NaV\[% #8RPYN_N[a$ Of V[`a_b Z R[a R[aVaYRQ% i 8RPYN_NaV\[ \S 7\cR[N[a`% 7\[QVaV\[` N[Q GR`a_VPaV\[`% 9YX U\_[ AN[QV[T 7\Z Z b [Vaf 5 ``\PVNaV\[% >[P'j #8RPYN_NaV\[$ QNaRQ B Nf */% *200% RSSRPaVcR 5 ]_VY+2% *200% N[Q V[aR[QRQ a\ OR _RP\_QRQ NZ \[T aur AN[Q GRP\_Q` \S =\d N_Q 7\b [af ]_V\_ UR_Ra\ N` \d [R_` N[Q QRcRY\]R_` \S aur [Rd `V[T YR SNZ VYf NaaNPURQ _R`VQR[aVNY P\Z Z b [Vaf V[ aur KVYYNT R \S Dd R[ 6_\d [ d UVPU V` X [\d [ N` i 9YX U\_[ AN[QV[T %j P_RNaRQ aur_rof PR_aNV[ _VT Ua`% YVNOVYVaVR`% V[aR_R`a`% P\cR[N[a`% P\[QVaV\[`% _R`a_VPaV\[`% OR[RSVa`% YVR[` N[Q \OYVT NaV\[` NSSRPaV[T `NVQ _RNY]_\]R_af N` aur_rv[qrsv[rq N[Q NYY ]_R`R[aN[Q Sb ab _R \d [R_` aur_r\s' HRPaV\[+', IUR 5 ``\PVNaV\[UR_ROf N[Q UR_RV[P\[SV_Z `% _NaVSVR` N[Q NQ\]a` V[NYY]N_aVPb YN_` aur ]_\cv`v\[` N[Q ar_z ` \S `NVQ 8RPYN_NaV\[ N[Q \S aur 5 _avpyr` \S >[P\_]\_NaV\[% V[PYb QV[T NYY QRSV[VaV\[` `Ra S\_aU aur_rv['!/1)#*% ))) 7 +%%1),'0 -& +%+"%/0 HRPaV\[,'* 5 [[b NYB RRaV[T `' 5 [[b NYB RRaV[T ` `UNYYOR URYQ V[aUR Z \[au \S DPa\OR_ \S RNPU frn_% b [YR`` \aur_d V`R QRaR_Z V[RQ Of aur 6\N_Q' 5 a RNPU 5 [[b NY B RRaV[T \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[% Z RZ OR_` `UNYYSVYYcNPN[PVR` \[aur 6\N_Q V[NPP\_QN[PR d VaU 5 _avpyr >K \S aur`r 6f&YNd `% `UNYY NQ\]a N[N[[b NYOb QT Ra% N[Q Z Nf NY`\ a_n[`npa `b PU \aur_ob `V[R`` N` Z Nf ]_\]R_Yf P\Z R ORS\_R aurz ' HRPaV\[,'+ H]RPVNYB RRaV[T `' H]RPVNYZ RRaV[T ` \S aur Z RZ OR_` Z Nf OR PNYYRQ Na N[f avz R Of aur ]_R`VQR[a \_ Of aur 6\N_Q% \_ b ]\[d _VaaR[_R^b R`a \S \[R&S\b _au #*(-$ \S aur Z RZ OR_` d U\ N_R R[aVaYRQ a\ c\ar'

2 HRPaV\[,', C\aVPR \S B RRaV[T `' L _VaaR[[\aVPR \S RNPU Z RRaV[T \S aur Z RZ OR_` `UNYYOR T VcR[ Of% \_ Na aur QV_RPaV\[\S% aur `RP_RaN_f \_ ]R_`\[Nb au\_vgrq a\ PNYY aur Z RRaV[T % Of Z NVYV[T N P\]f \S `b PU [\avpr [\a YR`` aun[*) QNf` [\_ Z \_R aun[,) QNf` ORS\_R `b PU Z RRaV[T a\ RNPU Z RZ OR_ R[aVaYRQ a\ c\ar aur_rna% NQQ_R``RQ a\ aur Z RZ OR_h` NQQ_R`` V[ 9YX U\_[ AN[QV[T YN`a N]]RN_V[T \[aur O\\X ` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[% \_ `b ]]YVRQ Of `b PU Z RZ OR_ a\ aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[S\_ aur ]b _]\`R \S [\avpr' Hb PU [\avpr `UNYY`]RPVSf aur ]YNPR% QNf N[Q U\b _ \S aur Z RRaV[T N[Q% V[ aur PN`R \S N`]RPVNYZ RRaV[T % aur ]b _]\`R \SaUR Z RRaV[T ' HRPaV\[,'- F b \_b Z ' IUR ]_R`R[PR% RVaUR_ V[]R_`\[\_ Of ]_\ef% \S Z RZ OR_` R[aVaYRQ a\ PN`a \[R&`VeaU #*(/$ \S aur c\ar` \S aur Z RZ OR_`UV]% `UNYY OR _R^b V`VaR S\_% N[Q `UNYY P\[`aVab ar N ^b \_b Z S\_aUR a_n[`npav\[\s Ob `V[R`` Na NYYZ RRaV[T ` \S Z RZ OR_`% RePR]a N` \aur_d V`R ]_\cvqrq V[aUR 5 _avpyr` \S >[P\_]\_NaV\[% aur 8RPYN_NaV\[% R`]RPVNYYf 5 _avpyr K>HRPaV\[ 0% \_ aur`r 6f& YNd `' >S `b PU ^b \_b Z `UNYY[\a OR ]_R`R[a \_ aur [b Z OR_ \S Z RZ OR_` Na NZ RRaV[T Q_\]` ORY\d aur ^b \_b Z N[Q aur ^b R`aV\[ \S N YNPX \S ^b \_b Z V` _NV`RQ% [\ Ob `V[R`` Z Nf aur_rnsar_ OR a_n[`nparq' IUR Z RZ OR_` ]_R`R[a aur_rna `UNYYUNcR aur ]\d R_a\ NQW\b _[aur Z RRaV[T N[Q PNYYN[ NQQVaV\[NY Z RRaV[T T VcV[T Na YRN`a *. QNf` d _VaaR[[\aVPR' IUR ]_R`R[PR% RVaUR_ V[]R_`\[\_ Of ]_\ef% \S Z RZ OR_` R[aVaYRQ a\ PN`a \[R&aR[aU #*(*) $ \S aur c\ar` \S aur Z RZ OR_`UV] `UNYY P\[`aVab ar aur _R^b V`VaR ^b \_b Z S\_ auv` NQQVaV\[NY Z RRaV[T ' >S auv` Z RRaV[T V` NY`\ YNPX V[T N ^b \_b Z % aur Z RZ OR_` ]_R`R[a aur_rna `UNYY UNcR aur ]\d R_ a\ NQW\b _[aur Z RRaV[T N[Q PNYY N `RP\[Q NQQVaV\[NY Z RRaV[T T VcV[T Na YRN`a *. QNf` d _VaaR[ [\avpr' 5 a aur `RP\[Q NQQVaV\[NY Z RRaV[T % aur Z RZ OR_` ]_R`R[aV[]R_`\[\_Of ]_\ef `UNYYP\[`aVab ar N^b \_b Z ' HRPaV\[,'. E_\eVR`' 5 a NYYZ RRaV[T ` \S Z RZ OR_`% RNPU Z RZ OR_Z Nf c\ar V[]R_`\[\_Of ]_\ef' 5 YY ]_\evr` `UNYY OR V[d _VaV[T V[aUR S\_Z N]]_\cRQ Of aur 6\N_Q% N[Q Z b `a OR SVYRQ d VaU aur `RP_RaN_f' 9cR_f ]_\ef `UNYY OR _Rc\PNOYR% `UNYY [\a OR RSSRPaVcR S\_ Z \_R aun[*+) QNf`% N[Q `UNYYNb a\z NaVPNYYf PRN`R b ]\[P\[cRfN[PR Of aur Z RZ OR_\SUV` Y\a' HRPaV\[,'/ K\aR' 5 Z NW\_Vaf c\ar \[ N[f V``b R ]_R`R[aRQ S\_ c\ar Na N[f Qb Yf PNYYRQ N[Q P\[`aVab arq Z RRaV[T % b [YR`` \aur_d V`R `anarq V[aUR 5 _avpyr` \S >[P\_]\_NaV\[% aur 8RPYN_NaV\[\_ aur`r 6f&YNd `% `UNYYOR SV[NYN[Q OV[QV[T \[aur 5 ``\PVNaV\['!/1)#*% )3 7 "-!/$ -& $)/%#1-/0 HRPaV\[-'* Cb Z OR_' IUR NSSNV_` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[`UNYY OR Z N[NT RQ Of N6\N_Q [b Z OR_V[T SVcR #.$% \_ `b PU \aur_ b [RcR[[b Z OR_ N` aur Z RZ OR_` Z Nf S_\Z avz R a\ avz R QR`VT [NaR' C\ PUN[T R V[aUR [b Z OR_ \S QV_RPa\_` `UNYY\]R_NaR a\ Pb _anvy\_ ReaR[Q aur ar_z \S N[f V[Pb Z OR[a QV_RPa\_' 5 YYQV_RPa\_` Z b `aor [Nab _NY]R_`\[` N[Q Z b `a OR Z RZ OR_` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[\ R`VQR \[5 ``\PVNaV\[]_\]R_af' HRPaV\[-'+ 9YRPaV\[N[Q IR_Z \S DSSVPR' 5 a RNPU N[[b NYZ RRaV[T % aur Z RZ OR_` `UNYYRYRPa Of d _VaaR[ONYY\a NQV_RPa\_ S\_ RNPU cnpn[pf S\_NaR_Z \S ad \ #+$ frn_`' IUR ]R_`\[#`$ _RPRVcV[T aur YN_T R`a [b Z OR_\S aur c\ar` `UNYYOR RYRPaRQ' 7b Z b YNaVcR c\av[t V` [\a ]R_Z VaaRQ' 8V_RPa\_` `UNYY U\YQ \SSVPR b [avyaurv_`b PPR``\_` UNcR ORR[RYRPaRQ N[Q U\YQ aurv_sv_`az RRaV[T ' 5 [f NZ R[QZ R[a a\ auv` `RPaV\[`UNYY[\a \]R_NaR a\ Pb _anvy\_rear[q aur ar_z \S N[f V[Pb Z OR[a QV_RPa\_' HRPaV\[ -', C\Z V[NaV\[`' C\Z V[NaV\[` S\_ RYRPaV\[ a\ aur 6\N_Q `UNYY OR _R^b R`aRQ \S aur Z RZ OR_` Of aur Pb R[a 6\N_Q Na YRN`a /) QNf` Ob a [\a Z \_R aun[2) QNf` ]_V\_ a\ aur N[[b NY Z RRaV[T ' C\Z V[NaV\[` `UNYY OR Z NQR V[ d _VaV[T % V[PYb QV[T Of RZ NVY% N[Q `b OZ VaaRQ a\ aur HRP_RaN_f' IUR [NZ R` \S NYY ^b NYVSVRQ [\Z V[RR` `UNYY N]]RN_ \[aur ONYY\a' C\Z V[NaV\[` Z Nf NY`\ OR Z NQR S_\Z aur SY\\_ Na aur N[[b NY Z RRaV[T ' IUR [NZ R` \S aur`r [\Z V[RR` `UNYY [\a N]]RN_\[aUR ONYY\aOb az Nf OR d _VaaR[V[' HRPaV\[ -'- GR`VT [NaV\[% GRZ \cny N[Q KNPN[PVR`' 5 [f QV_RPa\_ Z Nf OR _RZ \crq S_\Z aur 6\N_Q% d VaU \_ d VaU\b a PNb `R% Of N[NSSV_Z NaVcR c\ar \S Z \_R aun[.) " \S aur Z RZ OR_` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[' >[aur RcR[a \S QRNaU% _R`VT [NaV\[\ RZ \cny \S NQV_RPa\_% N`b PPR``\_ `UNYY OR

3 `RYRPaRQ Of aur _RZ NV[V[T Z RZ OR_` \S aur 6\N_Q N[Q `UNYY `R_cR S\_ aur _RZ NV[QR_ \S aur b [Re]V_RQ ar_z \S UV` ]_RQRPR``\_' HRPaV\[ -'. 7\Z ]R[`NaV\[' C\ QV_RPa\_ `UNYY _RPRVcR P\Z ]R[`NaV\[ S\_ N[f `R_cVPR UR Z Nf _R[QR_ a\ aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[' =\d RcR_% N[f QV_RPa\_ Z Nf OR _RVZ Ob _`RQ S\_ NPab NY Re]R[`R` V[Pb RQ V[aUR ]R_S\_Z N[PR \SUV` Qb avr`'!/1)#*% 3 7 *)!")*)16!,$ ),$%+,)&)#!1)-, -& -&&)#%/0!,$ $)/%#1-/0 HRPaV\[.'* AVNOVYVaf N[Q >[QRZ [VSVPNaV\[ \S DSSVPR_` N[Q 8V_RPa\_`' IUR 5 ``\PVNaV\[ `UNYY V[QRZ [VSf RcR_f \SSVPR_ N[Q QV_RPa\_ \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[NT NV[`a N[f N[Q NYY Re]R[`R`% V[PYb QV[T P\b [`RYSRR` _RN`\[NOYf V[Pb RQ Of \_ VZ ]\`RQ b ]\[N[f \SSVPR_ \_ QV_RPa\_ V[P\[[RPaV\[d VaU N[f NPaV\[% `b Va \_ \aur_ ]_\PRRQV[T #V[PYb QV[T aur `RaaYRZ R[a \S N[f `b PU `b Va \_ ]_\PRRQV[T VS N]]_\cRQ Of aur aur[6\n_q \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[$ a\ d UVPU UR Z Nf OR Z NQR N]N_af Of _RN`\[\S ORV[T \_ UNcV[T ORR[N[\SSVPR_ \_ QV_RPa\_ \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[d URaUR_ \_ [\_ `b PU ]R_`\[V` N[ \SSVPR_ \_ QV_RPa\_ Na aur avz R `b PU Re]R[`R` N_R V[Pb RQ' IUR \SSVPR_` N[Q QV_RPa\_` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[`UNYY[\a OR YVNOYR a\ aur B RZ OR_` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[S\_ N[f Z V`aNX R \S Wb QT Z R[a% [RT YVT R[PR% \_ \aur_d V`R% RePR]a S\_ aurv_ \d [V[QVcVQb NY d VYYSb YZ V`P\[Qb Pa \_ ONQ SNVaU' IUR \SSVPR_` N[Q QV_RPa\_` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[ `UNYY UNcR [\ ]R_`\[NY YVNOVYVaf d VaU _R`]RPa a\ N[f P\[a_NPa \_\aur_p\z Z VaZ R[a Z NQR Of aurz % V[T \\Q SNVaU% \[ORUNYS \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[#RePR]a a\ aur ReaR[a auna `b PU \SSVPR_` \_QV_RPa\_` Z Nf NY`\ OR \d [R_` \S A\a`$ N[Q aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[`UNYY V[QRZ [VSf N[Q S\_RcR_ U\YQ RNPU `b PU \SSVPR_ N[Q QV_RPa\_ S_RR N[Q UN_Z YR`` NT NV[`a N[f N[Q NYY YVNOVYVaf a\ \aur_` \[NPP\b [a \S N[f `b PU P\[a_NPa \_P\Z Z VaZ R[a' 5 [f _VT Ua a\ V[QRZ [VSVPNaV\[ ]_\cvqrq S\_ UR_RV[`UNYY[\a OR RePYb `VcR \S N[f \aur VT Ua` a\ d UVPU N[f \SSVPR_ \_ QV_RPa\_\S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[% \_S\_Z R_\SSVPR_\_QV_RPa\_\SaUR 5 ``\PVNaV\[Z Nf OR R[aVaYRQ' HRPaV\[.'+ 7\Z Z \[\_ >[ar_r`arq 8V_RPa\_`' IUR 8V_RPa\_` `UNYY ReR_PV`R aurv_ ]\d R_` N[Q Qb avr` V[T \\Q SNVaU N[Q d VaU NcVRd a\ aur OR`a V[aR_R`a` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[' C\ P\[a_NPa \_\aur_ a_n[`npav\[orad RR[aUR 5 ``\PVNaV\[N[Q \[R \_Z \_R \S Va` 8V_RPa\_`% \_ORad RR[aUR 5 ``\PVNaV\[ N[Q N[f P\_]\_NaV\[% SV_Z % \_ N``\PVNaV\[#V[PYb QV[T aur 8RPYN_N[a$ V[d UVPU \[R \_ Z \_R \S aur 8V_RPa\_` \S auv` 5 ``\PVNaV\[N_R QV_RPa\_` \_\SSVPR_` \_ N_R ]RPb [VN_VYf \_\aur_d V`R V[aR_R`aRQ% V` RVaUR_c\VQ \_c\vqnoyr ORPNb `R `b PU 8V_RPa\_\_8V_RPa\_` N_R ]_R`R[a Na aur Z RRaV[T \S aur 6\N_Q \_ N[f P\Z Z VaaRR aur_r\s d UVPU Nb au\_vgr` \_ N]]_\cR` aur P\[a_NPa S\_`b PU ]b _]\`R`% VS N[f \S aur P\[QVaV\[` `]RPVSVRQ V[N[f \S aur S\YY\d V[T `b O]N_NT _N]U` ReV`a3 #N$ IUR SNPa \S aur P\Z Z \[QV_RPa\_NaR \_V[aR_R`a V` QV`PY\`RQ \_X [\d [a\ aur 6\N_Q \_N Z NW\_Vaf aur_r\s \_ [\arq V[aUR B V[b ar`% N[Q aur 6\N_Q Nb au\_vgr`% N]]_\cR`% \ NaVSVR` `b PU P\[a_NPa \_a_n[`npav\[v[t \\Q SNVaU Of Nc\aR `b SSVPVR[a S\_aUR ]b _]\`R4 #O$ IUR SNPa \S aur P\Z Z \[QV_RPa\_NaR \_V[aR_R`a V` QV`PY\`RQ \_X [\d [a\ aur B RZ OR_`% \_ NZ NW\_Vaf aur_r\s% N[Q aurf N]]_\cR \ NaVSf aur P\[a_NPa \_ a_n[`npav\[v[t \\Q SNVaU Of N c\ar `b SSVPVR[aS\_aUR ]b _]\`R4 \_ #P$ IUR P\[a_NPa \_ a_n[`npav\[v` P\Z Z R_PVNYYf _RN`\[NOYR a\ aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[Na aur avz R Va V` Nb au\_vgrq% _NaVSVRQ% N]]_\cRQ \_ReRPb arq' 7\Z Z \[\_V[aR_R`aRQ 8V_RPa\_` Z Nf OR P\b [arq V[QRaR_Z V[V[T aur ]_R`R[PR \SN^b \_b Z Na N[f Z RRaV[T \S aur 6\N_Q \_ P\Z Z VaaRR aur_r\s d UVPU Nb au\_vgr`% N]]_\cR`% \ NaVSVR` N[f P\[a_NPa \_ a_n[`npav\[% N[Q Z Nf c\ar aur_rna a\ Nb au\_vgr N[f P\[a_NPa \_ a_n[`npav\[d VaU YVX R S\_PR N[Q RSSRPa N` VS UR d R_R [\a `b PU N QV_RPa\_ \_ \SSVPR_ \S `b PU P\_]\_NaV\[ \_ [\a `\ V[aR_R`aRQ'

4 !/1)#*% 3) 7.-4%/0!,$ $21)%0 -& 1(% "-!/$ HRPaV\[/'* E\d R_`' IUR 6\N_Q `UNYYUNcR aur ]\d R_a\3 #N$ 5 Q\]a N[Q ]b OYV`U _b YR` N[Q _RT b YNaV\[` T \cr_[v[t aur b `R \S aur 7\Z Z \[5 _RNN[Q SNPVYVaVR`% N[Q aur ]R_`\[NY P\[Qb Pa \S aur Z RZ OR_` N[Q aurv_ T b R`a` aur_r\[% N[Q a\ R`aNOYV`U ]R[NYaVR` S\_aUR V[S_NPaV\[` aur_r\s4 N[Q #O$ 9eR_PV`R S\_ aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[NYY]\d R_`% Qb avr` N[Q Nb au\_vaf cr`arq V[\_ QRYRT NaRQ a\ auv` 5 ``\PVNaV\[N[Q [\a _R`R_cRQ a\ aur Z RZ OR_`UV] Of \aur_ ]_\cv`v\[` \S aur`r 6f&YNd `% aur 5 _avpyr` \S>[P\_]\_NaV\[% \_aur 8RPYN_NaV\[4 N[Q #P$ 9Z ]Y\f NZ N[NT R_ N[Q `b PU \aur_ RZ ]Y\fRR` N` aur 6\N_Q QRRZ ` [RPR``N_f N[Q a\ ]_R`P_VOR aurv_qb avr`4 N[Q #Q$ Hb `]R[Q aur c\av[t _VT Ua` \S N[f Z RZ OR_ d U\ SNVY` a\ ]Nf aur N[[b NYN``R``Z R[a \_ \aur_d V`R SNVY` a\ P\Z ]Yf d VaU aur ar_z ` \SaUR 8RPYN_NaV\[\_aUR`R 6f&YNd `4 N[Q #R$ >Z ]\`R N[Q P\YYRPa YNaR SRR` \[ ]N`a Qb R N``R``Z R[a` [\a a\ RePRRQ SVSaRR[Q\YYN_` #! *.$ \_ar[]r_pr[a#*) " $ \SaUR N``R``Z R[a% d UVPURcR_V` T _RNaR_4 N[Q #S$ ; \_RPY\`R aur YVR[NT NV[`a N[f ]_\]R_af S\_ d UVPU N``R``Z R[a` N_R [\a ]NVQ NSaR_ aur Qb R QNaR \_ a\ O_V[T N[NPaV\[Na YNd NT NV[`a aur \d [R_ ]R_`\[NYYf \OYVT NaRQ a\ ]Nf aur `NZ R \_ O\aU' HRPaV\[/'+ 8b avr`' >a`unyyor aur Qb af \SaUR 6\N_Q a\3 #N$ 7Nb `R a\ OR X R]a NP\Z ]YRaR _RP\_Q \SNYYVa` NPa` N[Q P\_]\_NaR NSSNV_` N[Q a\ ]_R`R[a N `anarz R[a aur_r\s a\ aur Z RZ OR_` Na aur N[[b NY Z RRaV[T \S aur Z RZ OR_`% \_ Na N[f `]RPVNY Z RRaV[T d UR[`b PU `anarz R[a V` _R^b R`aRQ V[d _VaV[T Of \[R&S\b _au #*(-$ \S aur Z RZ OR_` d U\ N_R R[aVaYRQ a\ c\ar4 N[Q #O$ Hb ]R_cV`R NYY \SSVPR_`% NT R[a` N[Q RZ ]Y\fRR` \S auv` 5 ``\PVNaV\[% N[Q `RR auna aurv_ Qb avr` N_R ]_\]R_Yf ]R_S\_Z RQ4 N[Q #P$ E_R]N_R% \_PNb `R a\ UNcR ]_R]N_RQ% N[N[[b NYOb QT Ra S\_aUR 5 ``\PVNaV\[% N[Q ]_R`R[a auv` Ob QT Ra a\ aur Z RZ OR_` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[ S\_ N]]_\cNY Na aur N[[b NY Z RRaV[T \S aur Z RZ OR_`4 N[Q #Q$ 5 ` Z \_R Sb YYf ]_\cvqrq UR_RV[% N[Q V[aUR 8RPYN_NaV\[% a\3 #*$ ; VeaUR NZ \b [a \S aur N[[b NYN``R``Z R[a NT NV[`a RNPU A\a Na YRN`a auv_af #,) $ QNf` V[ NQcN[PR \S RNPU N[[b NY N``R``Z R[a ]R_V\Q% N` UR_RV[NSaR_ ]_\cvqrq V[ aur 8RPYN_NaV\[4 N[Q #+$ HR[Q d _VaaR[[\aVPR \S N``R``Z R[a a\ RcR_f Dd [R_ Na YRN`a auv_af #,) $ QNf` V[ NQcN[PR \S aur SV_`a QNf \S RNPU PNYR[QN_\_ SV`PNYfRN_Qb _V[T d UVPU N``R``Z R[a` `UNYYOR YRcVRQ4 N[Q #R$ E_\Pb _R N[Q Z NV[aNV[NQR^b NaR YVNOVYVaf N[Q UNgN_Q V[`b _N[PR \[]_\]R_af \d [RQ Of aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[4 N[Q #S$ 7Nb `R NYY \SSVPR_` N[Q RZ ]Y\fRR`% V[PYb QV[T aur Z N[NT RZ R[a NT R[a% UNcV[T SV`PNY _R`]\[`VOVYVaVR` a\ OR O\[QRQ \_V[`b _RQ% N` Va Z Nf QRRZ N]]_\]_VNaR4 N[Q #T $ 7Nb `R aur 7\Z Z \[ 5 _RN N[Q NYY \aur_ ]_\]R_af \d [RQ Of aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[ a\ OR ]_R`R_cRQ N[Q Z NV[aNV[RQ V[NPP\_QN[PR d VaU aur ]_\cv`v\[` \S aur 8RPYN_NaV\[4 N[Q #U$ 7Nb `R Dd [R_` a\ Z NV[aNV[NYY`a_b Pab _R`% V[PYb QV[T % Ob a [\a YVZ VaRQ a\% aur ReaR_V\_` \S U\b `R`% SR[PR`% _RaNV[V[T d NYY` N[Q `URQ` V[NPP\_QN[PR d VaU aur ar_z ` \SaUR 8RPYN_NaV\[4 N[Q

5 #V$ 7Nb `R auna ]\_av\[\s_r`vqr[pr A\a` [\ap\cr_rq \_R[PY\`RQ Of NU\b `R N[Q SR[PV[T a\ OR Z NV[aNV[RQ V[NPP\_QN[PR d VaU aur ar_z ` \S aur 8RPYN_NaV\['!/1)#*% 3)) 7 -&&)#%/0!,$ 1(%)/ $21)%0 HRPaV\[0'* 9[b Z R_NaV\[\S DSSVPR`' IUR \SSVPR_` \S auv` 5 ``\PVNaV\[`UNYYOR N]_R`VQR[a% NcVPR ]_R`VQR[a% N[Q Na_RN`b _R_% d U\ `UNYYNa NYYaVZ R` OR Z RZ OR_` \S aur 6\N_Q% N[Q N`RP_RaN_f' HRPaV\[ 0'+ 9YRPaV\[ N[Q IR_Z \S DSSVPR_`' IUR \SSVPR_` \S auv` 5 ``\PVNaV\[ `UNYY OR RYRPaRQ N[[b NYYf Of aur 6\N_Q' IURf `UNYYU\YQ \SSVPR S\_ \[R #*$ frn_b [YR`` aurf _R`VT [% N_R _RZ \crq% \_ N_R \aur_d V`R QV`^b NYVSVRQ a\ `R_cR' IUR RYRPaV\[ \S \SSVPR_` `UNYY anx R ]YNPR Na aur SV_`a Z RRaV[T \S aur 6\N_Q S\YY\d V[T RNPU N[[b NYZ RRaV[T \SaUR Z RZ OR_`' HRPaV\[0', H]RPVNY5 ]]\V[aZ R[a`' IUR 6\N_Q Z Nf RYRPa `b PU \aur_\ssvpr_` N` aur NSSNV_` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[Z Nf _R^b V_R% RNPU \S d U\Z `UNYY U\YQ \SSVPR S\_ `b PU ]R_V\Q% UNcR `b PU Nb au\_vaf% N[Q ]R_S\_Z `b PU Qb avr` N` aur 6\N_Q Z Nf% S_\Z avz R a\ avz R% QRaR_Z V[R' HRPaV\[0'- GR`VT [NaV\[% GRZ \cny% N[Q KNPN[PVR`' 5 [f \SSVPR_Z Nf _R`VT [Na N[f avz R Of T VcV[T d _VaaR[[\aVPR a\ aur 6\N_Q% aur ]_R`VQR[a% \_ aur `RP_RaN_f' Hb PU _R`VT [NaV\[`UNYYaNX R RSSRPa \[ aur QNaR \S _RPRV]a \S `b PU [\avpr \_ Na N[f YNaR_ avz R `]RPVSVRQ aur_rv[% N[Q b [YR`` \aur_d V`R `]RPVSVRQ aur_rv[% aur NPPR]aN[PR \S `b PU _R`VT [NaV\[`UNYY[\a OR [RPR``N_f a\ Z NX R Va RSSRPaVcR' J]\[aUR NSSV_Z NaVcR c\ar \S NZ NW\_Vaf \S Z RZ OR_` \S aur 6\N_Q% N[f \SSVPR_ Z Nf OR _RZ \crq% RVaUR_ d VaU \_ d VaU\b a PNb `R' IUR `b PPR``\_ a\ N[f \SSVPR_ d U\ _R`VT [` \_ V` _RZ \crq `UNYY OR RYRPaRQ Of aur 6\N_Q Na N[f _RT b YN_Z RRaV[T \S aur 6\N_Q% \_Na N[f `]RPVNYZ RRaV[T \S aur 6\N_Q PNYYRQ S\_ `b PU ]b _]\`R' IUR \SSVPR_RYRPaRQ a\ `b PU cnpn[pf `UNYY`R_cR S\_ aur _RZ NV[QR_\S aur b [Re]V_RQ ar_z \S aur \SSVPR_UR _R]YNPR`' HRPaV\[0'. B b YaV]YR DSSVPR`' IUR \SSVPR` \S `RP_RaN_f N[Q a_rn`b _R_ Z Nf OR URYQ Of aur `NZ R ]R_`\[' C\ ]R_`\[`UNYY`VZ b YaN[R\b `Yf U\YQ Z \_R aun[\[r \S N[f \S aur \aur_\ssvpr` RePR]a V[ aur PN`R \S`]RPVNY\SSVPR` P_RNaRQ ]b _`b N[a a\ HRPaV\[0', \SaUV` 5 _avpyr' HRPaV\[0'/ 8b avr`' IUR Qb avr` \S aur \SSVPR_` N_R N` S\YY\d `3 #N$ IUR ]_R`VQR[a `UNYY ]_R`VQR Na NYY Z RRaV[T ` \S aur 6\N_Q4 `UNYY `RR auna \_QR_` N[Q _R`\Yb av\[` \S aur 6\N_Q N_R PN VRQ \b a4 `UNYY `VT [ NYY Z \_at NT R`% QRRQ` N[Q \aur_ d _VaaR[ V[`a_b Z R[a`4 N[Q `UNYYOR N`VT [Na\_f \[NYY5 ``\PVNaV\[ON[X NPP\b [a`' #O$ IUR cvpr ]_R`VQR[a `UNYYNPa V[aUR ]YNPR N[Q `arnq \S aur ]_R`VQR[a V[aUR RcR[a \S aur ]_R`VQR[ah` NO`R[PR% V[NOVYVaf% \ RSb `NY a\ NPa4 `UNYY OR N `VT [Na\_f \[ NYY 5 ``\PVNaV\[ ON[X NPP\b [a`4 N[Q `UNYYReR_PV`R N[Q QV`PUN_T R `b PU \aur_qb avr` N` Z Nf OR _R^b V_RQ Of aur 6\N_Q' #P$ IUR a_rn`b _R_ `UNYYR[`b _R aur _RPRV]a N[Q QR]\`Va V[N]]_\]_VNaR ON[X NPP\b [a` \S NYY Z \[VR` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[N[Q `UNYYOR P\T [VgN[a \S aur QV`Ob _`NY \S `b PU Sb [Q` N` QV_RPaRQ Of _R`\Yb av\[\s aur 6\N_Q4 `UNYYOR N`VT [Na\_f \[NYYON[X NPP\b [a` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[4 `UNYYPNb `R ]_\]R_ O\\X ` \S NPP\b [a a\ OR X R]a4 `UNYY PNb `R N[N[[b NY Nb QVa \ RcVRd \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[ O\\X ` a\ OR Z NQR Of N]b OYVP NPP\b [an[a Na aur P\Z ]YRaV\[\S RNPU SV`PNYfRN_4 N[Q `UNYY]_R]N_R \_ PNb `R a\ OR ]_R]N_RQ N[ N[[b NY Ob QT Ra N[Q `anarz R[a \S V[P\Z R N[Q Re]R[QVab _R` S\_ `b OZ V``V\[ a\ N[Q NPaV\[ b ]\[ Of aur 6\N_Q% d UVPU Ob QT Ra `UNYY aur[ OR ]_R`R[aRQ a\ aur Z RZ OR_`UV] Na Va` N[[b NY Z RRaV[T S\_ N]]_\cNY aur_r\s' 5 SaR_ NQ\]aV\[% NP\]f \S aur N[[b NY Ob QT Ra `UNYYOR Z NQR NcNVYNOYR a\ RcR_f Z RZ OR_\SaUR 5 ``\PVNaV\[' #Q$ IUR `RP_RaN_f `UNYY _RP\_Q aur c\ar` N[Q X RR] aur Z V[b ar` \S NYY Z RRaV[T ` N[Q ]_\PRRQV[T ` \S aur 6\N_Q N[Q \S aur Z RZ OR_`4 `UNYYX RR] aur P\_]\_NaR `RNY\S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[ N[Q NSSVeVa \[NYY]N]R_` _R^b V_V[T `NVQ `RNY4 `UNYYPNb `R [\avpr \S NYYZ RRaV[T ` \S aur 6\N_Q N[Q \S aur Z RZ OR_` a\ OR `R_cRQ4 `UNYYX RR] \_ PNb `R a\ OR X R]a N]]_\]_VNaR Pb R[a _RP\_Q` `U\d V[T aur Z RZ OR_` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[a\T RaUR_d VaU aurv_nqq_r``r`4 N[Q `UNYY]R_S\_Z `b PU \aur_qb avr` N` _R^b V_RQ Of aur 6\N_Q'

6 !/1)#*% 3))) 7 +%%1),'0 -& 1(% "-!/$ -& $)/%#1-/0 HRPaV\[ 1'* GRT b YN_ B RRaV[T `' GRT b YN_ Z RRaV[T ` \S aur 6\N_Q `UNYY OR URYQ Z \[auyf \_ \aur_d V`R Na `b PU ]YNPR N[Q U\b _ N` Z Nf OR SVeRQ S_\Z avz R a\ avz R Of _R`\Yb av\[\s aur 6\N_Q% Ob a Na YRN`a S\b _#-$ avz R` ]R_SV`PNYfRN_' C\aVPR \S _RT b YN_Z RRaV[T ` \S aur 6\N_Q `UNYYOR T VcR[ a\ RNPU QV_RPa\_]R_`\[NYYf% Of Z NVY% R&Z NVY% \_ aryr]u\[r% Na YRN`a `Ve#/$ QNf` ]_V\_ a\ aur QNaR \S aur Z RRaV[T ' HRPaV\[1'+ H]RPVNYB RRaV[T `' H]RPVNYZ RRaV[T ` \S aur 6\N_Q `UNYYOR URYQ d UR[PNYYRQ Of aur ]_R`VQR[a \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[ \[ [\avpr T VcR[ a\ RNPU QV_RPa\_ ]R_`\[NYYf% Of Z NVY% R&Z NVY \_ aryr]u\[r Na YRN`a au_rr #,$ QNf` ]_V\_a\ aur QNaR \S aur Z RRaV[T ' Hb PU [\avpr `UNYY`aNaR aur avz R% ]YNPR N[Q ]b _]\`R \S Z RRaV[T ' H]RPVNY Z RRaV[T ` \S aur 6\N_Q `UNYY NY`\ OR PNYYRQ Of aur ]_R`VQR[a \_`RP_RaN_f \SaUR 6\N_Q V[NYVX R Z N[[R_b ]\[d _VaaR[_R^b R`a\SN[f ad \ #+$ QV_RPa\_`' HRPaV\[1', F b \_b Z ' 5 Z NW\_Vaf \S aur [b Z OR_ \S QV_RPa\_` `UNYYP\[`aVab ar N^b \_b Z S\_ aur a_n[`npav\[ \S Ob `V[R``' 9cR_f NPa \_ QRPV`V\[ Q\[R \_ Z NQR Of N Z NW\_Vaf \S aur QV_RPa\_` ]_R`R[a Na NQb Yf URYQ Z RRaV[T Na d UVPU N^b \_b Z V` ]_R`R[a `UNYYOR _RT N_QRQ N` aur NPa \S aur 6\N_Q' HRPaV\[ 1'- D]R[ B RRaV[T `' B RRaV[T ` \S aur 6\N_Q `UNYY OR \]R[ a\ NYY Z RZ OR_` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[% RePR]a auna Z RRaV[T ` URYQ S\_ aur ]b _]\`R` `anarq V[]N_NT _N]U **6&*** #-$ \S aur B N_fYN[Q =\Z R\d [R_` 5 ``\PVNaV\[5 Pa Z Nf OR URYQ V[PY\`RQ `R``V\[' HRPaV\[1'. 5 PaV\[INX R[L VaU\b a NB RRaV[T ' IUR QV_RPa\_` `UNYY UNcR aur _VT Ua a\ anx R N[f NPaV\[V[aUR NO`R[PR \S NZ RRaV[T % d UVPU aurf P\b YQ anx R Na NZ RRaV[T % Of \OaNV[V[T aur P\[`R[a \_ N]]_\cNY\S NZ NW\_Vaf \S aur QV_RPa\_`' 5 [f NPaV\[`\ N]]_\cRQ `UNYYUNcR aur `NZ R RSSRPa N` au\b T U anx R[Na NZ RRaV[T \S aur 6\N_Q' Hb PU NPaV\[` `UNYYOR _RP\_QRQ N[Q aur _RP\_Q N]]R[QRQ a\ aur Z V[b ar` \SaUR [Rea_RT b YN_Z RRaV[T '!/1)#*% )5 7 #-++)11%%0 HRPaV\[2'* IUR 6\N_Q `UNYYN]]\V[a `b PU P\Z Z VaaRR` N` N_R QRRZ RQ N]]_\]_VNaR a\ PN f \b a aur ]b _]\`R` \SaUR 5 ``\PVNaV\[' HRPaV\[2'+ >a `UNYYOR aur Qb af \S RNPU P\Z Z VaaRR a\ PN f \b a `b PU Sb [PaV\[` N[Q NPaVcVaVR` N` Z Nf OR N``VT [RQ a\ Va Of aur 6\N_Q' >[auv` _RT N_Q% RNPU P\Z Z VaaRR `UNYY_RPRVcR `b OZ V``V\[` \_ P\Z ]YNV[a` S_\Z Z RZ OR_` \[N[f Z NaaR_ V[c\YcV[T 5 ``\PVNaV\[Sb [PaV\[`% Qb avr`% N[Q NPaVcVaVR` d VaUV[Va` SVRYQ \S _R`]\[`VOVYVaf' >a `UNYY]_\]\`R _R`\Yb av\[\s `b PU Z NaaR_` a\ aur 6\N_Q \ RSR_ aurz a\ `b PU \aur_ P\Z Z VaaRR`% QV_RPa\_\_\SSVPR_\S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[N` V` Sb _aur_ P\[PR_[RQ d VaU aur Z NaaR_]_R`R[aRQ'!/1)#*% 5 7!+%,$+%,10 HRPaV\[*) '* IUR`R 6f&YNd ` Z Nf OR NZ R[QRQ% Na N_RT b YN_ \_ `]RPVNYZ RRaV[T \S aur Z RZ OR_`% Of N[NSSV_Z NaVcR c\ar \S ad \&auv_q` #+(,$ \S aur Z RZ OR_` ]_R`R[a V[]R_`\[\_ Of ]_\ef' 5 QR`P_V]aV\[ \S N[f ]_\]\`RQ NZ R[QZ R[a d VYY NPP\Z ]N[f aur [\avpr \S N[f N[[b NY \_ `]RPVNY Z RRaV[T \SaUR Z RZ OR_` Nad UVPU `b PU ]_\]\`RQ NZ R[QZ R[a V` a\ OR P\[`VQR_RQ N[Q c\arq b ]\['!/1)#*% 5) 7 '%,%/!*./-3)0)-,0 HRPaV\[**'* 7\[SYVPa ORad RR[5 _avpyr` \S >[P\_]\_NaV\[N[Q 6f&YNd `' >[aur PN`R \S N[f P\[SYVPa ORad RR[aUR 5 _avpyr` \S >[P\_]\_NaV\[N[Q aur`r 6f&YNd `% aur 5 _avpyr` `UNYY P\[a_\Y4 N[Q V[aUR PN`R \S N[f P\[SYVPa ORad RR[aUR 8RPYN_NaV\[N[Q aur`r 6f&YNd `% aur 8RPYN_NaV\[`UNYYP\[a_\Y' HRPaV\[**'+ ; V`PNY MRN_' IUR SV`PNY frn_ \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[`UNYY ORT V[\[aUR SV_`a QNf \S?N[b N_f N[Q R[Q \[aur,*`a QNf \S 8RPRZ OR_\S RcR_f frn_'

7 HRPaV\[**', >[`]RPaV\[\S aur 6\\X `' IUR O\\X ` N[Q NPP\b [a` \S aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[% c\b PUR_` NPP_RQVaV[T aur R[a_VR` Z NQR aur_rb ]\[% N[Q NYY\aUR RP\_Q` Z NV[aNV[RQ Of aur 5 ``\PVNaV\[% `UNYY OR NcNVYNOYR S\_ ReNZ V[NaV\[Of aur Z RZ OR_` N[Q aurv_ Qb Yf Nb au\_vgrq NT R[a` \_ Naa\_[Rf`% N[Q a\ aur V[`aVab av\[ny U\YQR_ \S N[f SV_`a Z \_at NT R \[N[f A\a N[Q Va` Qb Yf Nb au\_vgrq NT R[a` \_ Naa\_[Rf`% NSaR RN`\[NOYR [\avpr% Qb _V[T [\_Z NY Ob `V[R`` U\b _` N[Q S\_ ]b _]\`R` _RN`\[NOYf _RYNaRQ a\ aurv R`]RPaVcR V[aR_R`a`' HRPaV\[**'- 7\_]\_NaR HRNY' IUR 5 ``\PVNaV\[`UNYYUNcR N`RNYV[PV_Pb YN_S\_Z UNcV[T NY\[T Va` PV_Pb Z SR_R[PR aur d \_Q`3 9YX U\_[ AN[QV[T 7\Z Z b [Vaf 5 ``\PVNaV\[% >[P'% N[Q d VaUV[ Va` PV_Pb Z SR_R[PR aur d \_Q`3 B N_fYN[Q% *200' HRPaV\[ **'. HRcR_NOVYVaf' >[ aur RcR[a N[f ]_\cv`v\[ \S aur`r 6f&YNd ` `UNYY OR QRaR_Z V[RQ V[cNYVQ% c\vq \_b [R[S\_PRNOYR% `b PU QRaR_Z V[NaV\[`UNYY[\a _R[QR_V[cNYVQ% c\vq \_b [R[S\_PRNOYR N[f \aur_]_\cv`v\[` UR_R\S% d UVPU PN[OR T VcR[RSSRPa' HRPaV\[**'/ L NVcR_' C\ _R`a_VPaV\[% P\[QVaV\[% \OYVT NaV\[\_]_\cV`V\[\SaUR`R 6f&YNd ` `UNYYOR QRRZ RQ a\ UNcR ORR[NO_\T NaRQ \_d NVcRQ Of _RN`\[\SN[f SNVYb _R a\ R[S\_PR aur `NZ R' HRPaV\[ **'0 < R[QR_% RaP' L UR[RcR_ V[ aur`r 6f&YNd ` aur P\[aRea `\ _R^b V_R`% aur `V[T b YN_ [b Z OR_ `UNYYV[PYb QR aur ]Yb _NYN[Q aur P\[cR_`R% N[Q aur b `R \S N[f T R[QR_ `UNYYOR QRRZ RQ a\ V[PYb QR NYYT R[QR_`'

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/21/2014 INDEX NO /2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 33 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/12/2014

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/21/2014 INDEX NO. 153588/2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 33 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/12/2014 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK CENTENNIAL ELEVATORS INDUSTRIES, INC.