Comparisons- Nippur. Comparisons Rubeidheh (north of Diyala) Young and Levine 1974:75, fig. 14

Transcription

1 Comparative Pottery Table Comparative Typology of Period VI Pottery from Godin Tepe Revised April, 2008 Pottery Type Plain Godin Tepe Pottery Form Vertical or Slightly Flared, Carinated Body Painted Vertical or Slightly Flared, Carinated Body Slipped Vertical or Slightly Flared, Carinated Body Unslipped, pedestal or flat base IVb Period VI:2 (e) Vertical Sided Uruk Type Id Period VI:1 (d) Comparison s Chogha Mish Comparison s - Farukhabad Comparison s Kungi Cave Comparisons- Nippur Nippur XVII- XVIII(7NP292), 7NP 283 (XVII?) Comparisons Rubeidheh (north of Diyala) Fig. 28:15, T12 Comparisons Seh Gabi Young and Levine 1974:75, fig. 14 Comparisons Sialk (Ghirshman 1938) Sialk IV,1 Plate XXVII(3), XCS.1681 Sialk IV.1 with pedestal base Plate XC, S. 244 (12.5 H, 13 rd) Comparison s - Susa Comparisons - Warka Beakers Beakers Slightly flared, painted design Id Period VI:1 (c) cylindrical tumblers or small cups slipped IVc ; VI:2 (a,b,c,d); VI:3 (a) cups, painted Plate 80:C; Plate 83 A, B, C, D, E Fig. 31:53, T46, 95 cf Godin VI:2 (a) Sialk IV Plate XC, S.31 (11.5 H, 7.5 rd) Sialk III Plate LXVI, cf striped bowl Susa 17A, DAFI I fig. 46:16 Warka, Eanna VI, Haller 1932, pl. 19B:u

2 IVc VI:3 (b,c); VI:1 (b) S.1547, S.176 Plain Plain Plain Flared (no carination) Unslipped Flared (no carination) Beveled Very Flared Unslipped Id, VI:2 (b, c) Nippur Middle Uruk Conical Cup 7N795, XVII-XVIII (= Chron.'65, Fig. 5) Nippur: XVII, 7NP 279 Fig. 28:6, T6 Sialk IV Plate IV, S.33, wheel made with string cut base (4.5 H, 7.5 rd) Susa 17B2, DAFI 9, Fig. 19:8; Susan 17B1, Fig. 19:9 Beveled Bowls Uruk Beveled Bowls IA (c) Plate 83M-S increase in the number of Bevel Bowls in level XVI Hansen and Wilson date to beginning of the Late Uruk period (Hansen 1965; Wilson 1986) Fig. 28:1, T1 Sialk IV Plate XC, S.34 (6 H, rd 13) Beveled Bowls Uruk Beveled tall variant Weiss & Young 1975:7, fig. 3:5 IA VI:1 (b) none Sialk IV Plate XC, S.537 (15 H, rd 16) Susa 17, DAFI I, Fig. 47:12 Inturned Painted IC

3 Stance Rolled or Beaded Rolled or Beaded Rolled or Beaded VI:3 (b) Slipped IC VI:3 (a) Unslipped IC VI:2 (a) Variation IC VI:3 (c) Vertical or Slightly Flared Cream Slipped IB VI:3 (a): VI:2 (a, b) Vertical or Slightly Flared Red Slipped IB VI:1 (b) Flared Slipped IB Constricted Slipped Constricted Slipped, IB VI:2 (c); VI:3 (b) Constricted Slipped, Raised Fig. 28:13, T11, 22 Susa 17, DAFI I, Fig. 46:17

4 Plain Plain and IB VI:1 (c); VI:2 (d) Vertical or Flared Stance Plain Plain Rolled or Beaded Ledge s with Interior Bevel Ic VI:2 (a, b) Ie VI:2 (a) Vertical or Flared Stance Slipped Ib Pinched rolled rim VI:2 (a) Vertical or Flared Stance Slipped and Raised and Flared Stance, Plate 87G, Family LI Nippur XVI- XVII (7NP 277) Flared Stance Middle Uruk Nippur levels Fig. 29:27, T27 Seh Gabi 13:14 Susa 17 B, DAFI , Fig. 23:16, 17 Uruk Haller 1932 Taf. 19D:t

5 Expanded Ledge s Pots VII type XX (not registered) and XIX (7NP 307 variant) Bottles Bottles Bottles Bottles Rolled Painted IVd, VI:3 (a) Beveled IVd, VI:1 (b, e) Plain IVd, VI:1 (a, d) Folded Over IVd, VI:1 (c) IIb VI:1 (a,b,c,d,e,f) VI:2 (a,b,c,d,e) VI:3 (a) Godin OpB21 #306, #307; B20 #241; B18?19 #187; BKC N3 34 #80 Plate 111 Tepe Farukhabad Uruk (Wright 1981:Fig. 42E) Nippur level XV (7NP 322) Nippur XVI (7NP257). Nippur Level XV (7NP246) Nippur XV (7NP251) Susa 17B, DAFI 9, Fig. 30:1,2 Susa 17, Fig. 7:8; Susa 17B, DAFI 9, Fig. 30:9 Susa 17B2, DAFI 9, Fig. 25:13 (cf VI:1 a); Susa 17B1, DAFI 9, Fig. 25:10 (cf VI:1d); Susa 17B1, DAFI 9, Fig. 25:7 (cf VI:1e); Susa 25, DAFI I, Fig. 40:6 (cf. VI:2b) Tapered Beveled Nippur level XX (7N815) rim edge? Nippur XV (7NP251) rim edge?

6 Tall Plain Tall Plain Jar B01 56 #22, joined to A01 44, old break cf B1 526 to be drawn IIe (needs to be changed from IId), Pl. 94F, Family LXXXV Nippur XVIII (7N796 - without neck or base) Nippur XIX Tall Plain Jar (7NP311). cf Susa 17, DAFI I, Fig. 53(5); Susa 17B, DAFI 9, Fig. 29:1,3 Warka cf. UVB XIX, Taf. 39:O Painted Striped Raised and IIa without lug, VI:1 (g) Uruk 4-Lugged, IIa VI:1 (e, f) Uruk 4-Lugged,, Cross Hatched Triangles Gd IIa VI:1 (d) Pl. 122 B, G, H, Family CXXVIII Nippur level XX (7NP 317) and continue into level XVIII, but with a short thickened collar (as Nippur jars 7NP 294, XVIII or 7NP 299, XVIII). At Nippur this decoration first appears in level XVI (Nippur XVI 7NP263 Cross Hatched Triangle Jar [Chron.65:205, Fig.21]), but continues later in the JN Killick ed Fig. 34:99, T43, 77b, 88b,c Siyalk IV, Plate LXXXVIII, S. 21 Susa 17, DAFI I, Fig. 50:1; Susa 17, DAFI I, Fig. 51:2,5 Susa 17 Fig. 5:,9, Fig. 7:14 Uruk IV (UVB IV, Taf. 20A1)

7 , Size VII type fine jar beer with handle(s) wine Jar? Bodies with Exterior Knobs Uruk 4-Lugged,, with Painted IIa VI:1 (b decoration at carination; c- decoration immediately below rope ) Uruk 4-Lugged,, red slipped IIa,, Pl. 114:H, Family CXXI period. Siyalk Period IV, Plate LXXXVIII, S. 62 (plain) neckless fine jars with a plain slightly flaring rim IId VII (a) globular collar necked jars with one or two handles Iva VI:1 (a,b) tall piriform jars with vertical rope decoration Gd73-112;Gd (not illustrated see photo) Kantor 1966, Pl. 99B-C, Family XCV XVI Nippur jar fragment (7NP 262) Seh Gabi page 73, fig. 13:6 Sialk IV,2 Plate XC, S.77, vessel with Susa 17, DAFI I, Fig. 53:4, cf painted stripes at carination cf Susa 17, alabaster, DAFI fig. 54(2) Warka Sammulung in Heidelberg.

8 two openings Pithoi s Pithos Rolled Ve Period VI:2 (a, b, c, d) Pot Raised Band with Thumb Impressions Ve, Period VI:3 (a) Tepe Farukhabad Middle Uruk level B33 (Wright 1981, Fig. 41P) Steve & Gasche 1971, pl. 34:16 level 21 m 63; pl. 34:17; Pl. 90:10, 11 Pithoi Bodies Pithos Body Interior Applications Goat appliqué cf Choga Mish pottery relief Spouted Spouted Spouted Spouted Spouted Straight Spouts III, Period VI:2 (a) Short Spouts III VI:1 (b) small rolled rim bowl with cannon spout III VI:2 (c) Short Funnel Spouts III VI:2 (b) Trough Spouts III VI:1 (c) cf Delougaz and Kantor 1996 Plate 84:X Pl. 85:D, E, F, G, H attached to Nippur (level XX SPOUTED JAR - 7N816) - Nippur XX XVII (Nippur XVII: 7NP281) - Nippur XIX 7N808 but on bowls, not jars Fig. 36:115, 116, T82 Fig. 35:114, T81, 86b Fig. 35:105, T78 Sialk III, Plate LXIX, S.135 Sialk IV, Plate LXXXIX, S.43b funnel spout same vessel type: Siyalk IV, Plate LXXXVIII S.68, S.41 Susa 17, LeBrun 1978b, fig. 24:9, 10

9 Spouted Strainers Droop Spouts III Cooking Vd, Period VI:2 Tall Serving Uruk Rolled Va, Uruk Plain Va Vc VI:1 (a,b) bowls, cf Nippur Plate 111, Family CXVI cf Delougaz and Kantor 1996 Plate 86 DD Plate 86:R, S, X, Y, Z Family XLVIf, XLVIb, XLVId Plate 86 cf EE Plate 81:N, Family XI Nippur (illustrated in Chronologies 1965, Fig. 17 & 18) level XVII- XV. Nippur XIX tray - Chron.'65, Fig. 8 specific type? Nippur XVII (7NP 286) [also 2 examples from XVII- XVIII Nippur XVI- XVII 7n784 (note: pebbly grit!) (plain), S.115, S.52, S.40, S.538 (decorated with stripes) Sialk IV, Plate LXXXIX, S.43d droop spout fragment Sialk Chantier 1 (1933); Amiet 1985: 301, fig. 4, Louvre AO with thumbprint Susa 18, LeBrun 1978b, fig. 34:8; Susal 17B, LeBrun 1978a, fig. 30:7-14; Susa 17, LeBrun 1971, fig. 52:5 Fig. 37:140, T101;rim has interior lip none LeBrun 1978a, fig. 34:10 (Susa, Acropole I, Lenzen 1959a, pl. 21:f; Haller 1932, pls. 18 D:a ; 19b, p ; 19 D:v; 20 A:o,r (Warka, Eanna VII, VI, V, IV); Lenzen 1959a, pl. 32:f (Warka, Steinstiftempel) ; Nissen 1970, pls. 96:84; 97:9-11, 17, 18 (Warka, K/L Sounding, Layers 39, 37)

10 Strainers Vc VI:2 (a,b) Funnels none Lids Plain VI:3 (a) none Lids with Handle none Level 17B; LeBrun 1971, fig. 45:3 (Susa, Acropole I, Level 17) Bases - Flat Plain Fig. 37:129, T96 Bases - Flat Scraped Bases Flat Bases Disk Bases Ring Bases - Pedestal Bases - Pedestal Bases - Pedestal String Cut Nippur XV (7N775) GBT with string cut base (inside bitumin coated) Plain, Tapered Plain, Beveled Painted, Tapered Kungi Cave Fig. 6: r,s Fig. 37:130, T97 Sialk III, Plate LXXII, ring or disk bases Sialk III, Plate LXXII, ring or disk bases none Sialk IV,1 Plate XC S.244, S36 none* Sialk III, Plate LXX, S.1770 plain beveled pedestal none Sialk III,5 (Pl. LXIII, LXIV)