Rethinking the Fashion Collection as a Design Strategic Tool in a Circular Economy

Similar documents
COMMUNICATION ON ENGAGEMENT DANISH FASHION INSTITUTE

SAC S RESPONSE TO THE OECD ALIGNMENT ASSESSMENT

Dutch Circular Textiles Platform

Subject : Apparel Merchandising. Unit 1 Introduction to apparel merchandising. Quadrant 1 e-text

S R I L A N K A APPAREL

The Sustainable Future of the Fashion Industry

University of Huddersfield Repository

Case Study Example: Footloose

Consumer and Market Insights: Skincare Market in France. CT0027IS Sample Pages November 2014

Case study example Footloose

Master's Research/Creative Project Four Elective credits 4

Current calls for papers and announcements

BINDIS TOOLKIT. In This Issue. Steps for Bindi development. Measures of Success. Annex: Sustainable models for bindis. 3.

Rethinking the Roles of Fashion Designers. Chun, Namkyu

Clothing longevity and measuring active use

Fabric for Fashion / Clive Hallett & Amanda Johnston

COMPETENCIES IN CLOTHING AND TEXTILES NEEDED BY BEGINNING FAMILY AND CONSUMER SCIENCES TEACHERS

Proactive Fashion Design and New Green Business Thinking

Fashion Enter. Southampton, May 2014 Foster eco-innovation and social responsibility in the T&C industry

TO STUDY THE RETAIL JEWELER S IMPORTANCE TOWARDS SELLING BRANDED JEWELLERY

Higher National Unit Specification. General information for centres. Fashion: Commercial Design. Unit code: F18W 34

The Higg Index 1.0 Index Overview Training

Title Page Textile Waste in Skagit County Program Proposal. Emily Cone and Whitaker Jamieson. WWU Office of Sustainability

This unit is an optional unit included in the framework of the SQA Advanced Certificate /Diploma in Retail Management.

Retail Marketing Project at De-Lemon, a Unit of Banaras Beads Ltd. Nikita Ajwani PGDM Number Mousumi Sengupta Professor-HRM

Tips for proposers. Cécile Huet, PhD Deputy Head of Unit A1 Robotics & AI European Commission. Robotics Brokerage event 5 Dec Cécile Huet 1

The H&M group reaches customers around the world

ISTANBUL APPAREL EXPORTERS ASSOCIATION

INDIAN APPAREL MARKET OUTLOOK

EMOTIONAL FIT: Developing a new fashion methodology with older women

Resource for Teachers

OPEN CALL. WoSoF - WORLD SYMPOSIUM FOR FASHION. JEWELLERY. ACCESSORIES. Deadline : 10th November TONGJI University D&I, SHANGHAI 16th/DEC/2018.

Sampling Process in garment industry

Apparel, Textiles & Merchandising. Business of Fashion. Bachelor of Science

About the Report. Booming Women Apparel Market in India

Growth and Changing Directions of Indian Textile Exports in the aftermath of the WTO

FF: Fashion Design-Art (See also AF, AP, AR, DP, FD, TL)

The Portrayal Of Female Fashion Magazine (Rayli) And Chinese Young Women s Attitudinal And Behavioral Change

Visual Standards - Merit Level 3 Diploma in Art & Design. VISUAL STANDARDS - Merit

2018 LIZ CLAIBORNE DESIGN SCHOLARSHIP AWARD LIZ CLAIBORNE

China Textile and Apparel Production and Sales Statistics, Jul. 2014

2009 Career Advisers Seminar

FASHION WITH TEXTILES DESIGN BA (HONS) + FASHION BUSINESS BA (HONS) + FOUNDATION IN FASHION. Programmes are validated by:

State of. Reuse. Report

Shirts and blouses to perfection

BA Fashion, Marketing and Retailing Course Catalogue

Address by CEO Karl-Johan Persson at H&M s AGM 2017

Natural & Organic Cosmetics: Meeting Consumer Expectations. 5 th November NATRUE: The International Natural and Organic Cosmetics Association

From fiber to apparel: closing loops along the value chain Robert van de Kerkhof, Chief Commercial Officer. Fashion Summit HK, 7 th September 2017

Gloria Jeans brand awareness in Russia reaches 95% (based on data from McKinsey consulting company, 2014).

The Denim Industry. When shopping for jeans, individuals have different preferences and needs. Regardless of

INFLUENCE OF FASHION BLOGGERS ON THE PURCHASE DECISIONS OF INDIAN INTERNET USERS-AN EXPLORATORY STUDY

minutes academic Consumption of tattoos Getting, Having and Being Abstract on the web

Branded and Non Branded Jewellery

State of. Reuse. Report

Natural & Organic Cosmetics: Meeting Consumer Expectations Based on the results of a Consumer Inquiry commissioned to GfK by NATRUE

Overview of Taiwan Textile Industry 2013

Guidance on design for longevity underwear

DIFFERENCES IN GIRTH MEASUREMENT OF BMI BASED AND LOCALLY AVALIABLE CATEGORIES OF SHIRT SIZES

DESIGN & SOCIAL CONTEXT Submission to Academic Development and Students Committee

Cilotex CIRCULAR LOGISTICS A NEED FOR MORE TRACEABILITY? JAN MERCKX

COMPANY PROFILE. For Wholesale & Distribution: Reflex Holding FZCO P.O. Box Dubai, (U.A.E.)

New design and business models for sustainable consumption:

More than just looks, fashion is the understanding of THE practices and culture BEHIND the production and consumption of clothes, our second skin.

100% LEADING THE CHANGE

100% recycled polyester PET woven fabric for Italian. fashion SME

Fashion Footwear and accessories Beauty Lifestyle

This unit is suitable for those who have no previous qualifications or experience.

CONSCIOUS ACTIONS Sustainability Report 2014

Conscious Actions Highlights 2015


Innovation Topics in the Baltic Sea Region

Comparison of Women s Sizes from SizeUSA and ASTM D Sizing Standard with Focus on the Potential for Mass Customization

INDIAN JEWELLERY MARKET-METAMORPHOSIS INTRODUCTION

EU POLICY IN THE TEXTILE AND CLOTHING SECTOR

edited by Frank TPiller RWTH Aachen University, Germany Mitchell M Tseng The Hong Kong University of Science & Technology, Hong Kong World Scientific

UNIQLO UNIQLO, FUELING CLOTHING INNOVATION

SALES (EURO 7.94 BLN) AND TRADE SURPLUS (EURO 2.3 BLN) FOR

It is estimated that 350,000 tonnes of textiles goes to landfill in the UK every year at a staggering value of 140 million.

Community Services Committee 14 December Report for Decision. The Eden Hore Collection Building from the Feasibility Study (COM )

Course Bachelor of Fashion Design. Course Code BFD16. Location City Campus, St Kilda Road

The Study on the Development and Processing Transfer of Lip Balm Products from Virgin Coconut Oil: A Case Study

Global Breast Implants Market Analysis and Forecast

APPAREL, MERCHANDISING AND DESIGN (A M D)

Wardrobe Planning CIP

Export Success and Industrial Linkages

Chapter Objectives. Garment Styling. Garment Styling. Chapter Objectives 1/23/12. Beyond Design

Designing Garments with Evolving Aesthetics in Emergent Systems

2008 in figures Year in brief

Fashion Make-up: Runway and Editorial Make-up and Hair Skills (SCQF level 7)

Guidance on design for longevity casualwear

FEBRUARY 2018: A NEW ORGANISATION OF THE FASHION INFORMATION AT PREMIÈRE VISION PARIS

Mexico and the Global Apparel Industry

You wear new clothes for three years, you own them for another three years, and you repair them for yet another three years

Memory Ecotrust. ReForm Modular by THE URGE TO EXPLORE SPACE

China Home Textile Industry Report, Apr. 2013

Fashion Design, A.A.S.

The Business of Textile and Fashion

Life Science Journal 2015;12(3s) A survey on knowledge about care label on garments by Residents in Egypt

Study of consumer's preference towards hair oil with special reference to Karnal city

Transcription:

The Design Journal An International Journal for All Aspects of Design ISSN: 1460-6925 (Print) 1756-3062 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/rfdj20 Rethinking the Fashion Collection as a Design Strategic Tool in a Circular Economy Ulla Ræbild & Anne Louise Bang To cite this article: Ulla Ræbild & Anne Louise Bang (2017) Rethinking the Fashion Collection as a Design Strategic Tool in a Circular Economy, The Design Journal, 20:sup1, S589-S599, DOI: 10.1080/14606925.2017.1353007 To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/14606925.2017.1353007 2017 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group Published online: 06 Sep 2017. Submit your article to this journal Article views: 137 View related articles View Crossmark data Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalinformation?journalcode=rfdj20

Design for Next 12th EAD Conference Sapienza University of Rome 12-14 April 2017 doi: 10.1080/14606925.2017.1353007 Rethinking the Fashion Collection as a Design Strategic Tool in a Circular Economy Ulla Ræbilda*, Anne Louise Banga a Design School Kolding, Denmark *Corresponding author e-mail: ur@dskd.dk Abstract: The fashion industry is currently undergoing a radical change towards an overall sustainable paradigm shift. This paper investigates how the fashion collection, as a particular design framework, might be reconfigured as a strategic driver for garment longevity furthering sustainable fashion design. The study builds on a case study of a company offering a subscription service for baby clothing, exploring in detail whether and how the collection is used as a strategic design tool. In the analysis and discussion, feedback from users, manufacturers and the garments themselves plays a crucial role in the development of the collection. To some degree this differs from the development of a linear fashion collection. The paper concludes by suggesting a framework for using the collection as a strategic design tool designing garments for a product service system while adopting a circular economy thinking. Keywords: Circular Economy, Sustainable Fashion Design, Fashion Collection, Strategic Design, Garment Rental Systems 1. Introduction The fashion industry is currently undergoing a radical change. On the one hand, ever faster speed to market is driven by fast fashion logics and social media. Simultaneously there is talk and signs of an overall sustainable paradigm shift driven by the increasing body of data on the negative environmental and social impact of fashion production and consumption (e.g. Fletcher & Grose 2012; Fletcher & Tham 2015; Gardetti & Torres 2013). Yet, within this setting of change, the notion of the fashion collection (i.e. a range of garment designs that are seasonally determined, Renfrew & Renfrew 2009) seems to prevail as a predominant format for designing and marketing fashion garments, even though fast fashion s continuous and rapid influx of garments has brought about an acceleration in the industry at large. Whether this is due to industry conservatism and reluctance to innovate, or whether the collection format lingers for other reasons is hard to determine, as the subject of the collection is underresearched. While there is a large body of research on the topics of fashion design process and creativity, (e.g. Le Pechoux et al. 2012; Sinha 2002) little attention has been payed to the role the collection might play within fashion design practice and consumption, let alone its possible strategic potential. This is somewhat of a paradox, since the notion of the collection seems to be key to the way fashion is communicated. However, we find that not only the fast fashion system but also the 2017 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. S589

ULLA RÆBILD, ANNE LOUISE BANG seasonally tied collection system can be viewed as problematic from a sustainability perspective, as both build on a linear logic of continued replacement of old garments with new. In this paper we will refer to the seasonal collection system and the fast fashion system collectively as linear systems. This study investigates how the collection, as a particular design framework, might be reconfigured as a strategic driver for garment longevity furthering sustainable fashion design. The paper is based on a case study of Vigga, a Danish company that has adopted a circular business model, offering a subscription service for eco-certified baby clothing. Due to the limited data (single case) and the highly segmented field (children s garments) we propose to view the outcome of this investigation as indicative pointing to potentials. 2. Theoretical Framework The topic of the paper addresses issues relevant for the sustainable development that is currently taking place within the fashion and textile industry. Therefore the fashion and sustainability research field constitutes a contextual backdrop, as explicated in the introduction. More specifically the paper addresses ways in which fashion and garment design can be conducted within a circular business model. Hence the paper enters the discourse of new evolving business models building on services and a circular re-use of products and resources. Although designers are often bound by the objectives and strategies of companies which may lie far beyond the designer s reach we align with the viewpoints of Botsman & Rogers (2011) that designers must stop focusing on thingification and address the ecological impact of the products they design, thus they must help find a balance between the needs of the consumers and companies and the collective interest of society (ibid: 187). The authors propose three overall strategies to support such a development: product service systems; redistribution markets and collaborative lifestyles (ibid: xvi). A further understanding of how such circular strategies can be carried out on a practical level from a business perspective has been adopted from Lacy & Rutquist (2015), who view the transition to a circular economy as perhaps the biggest revolution and opportunity for how we organise production and consumption in our global economy in 250 years (ibid: xv). The key element in the authors thinking is to turn waste into wealth, and they identify four areas where waste holds potential for circular business (ibid: xvii): 1. Wasted resources (materials and energy consumed and lost); 2. Wasted lifecycles (artificially short lifecycles); 3. Wasted capabilities (unused or idle products) and 4. Wasted embedded values (unrecovered components, materials and energy from disposed products). From the many presented models, we find that The Product Life-Extension Business Model: Products That are Built to Last reflects the present case, as the model implements Resell, Repair & Upgrade, as well as Refurbish & Re-manufacture practices (ibid: 68-70). Lastly the paper addresses how the collection might be a strategic tool in a design practice aiming for circularity. Renfrew & Renfrew (2016) offer practice-based how to guidelines for the development of collections. They see the collection as a range of garments brought together to tell a story and designed for a season or particular occasion (ibid: 9). Their understanding of the collection is closely tied to the practised design and manufacturing process, i.e. the different stages that garments undergo from initial inspiration to the final showcase of a finished collection. It is thus focusing on the processual aspects of the development, leaving out the question of how the actual content of the collection is decided upon. Nixon & Blakley (2012) see the notion of collection as a broader methodological approach, as both a noun and a vowel, a sampling and collecting in time and space, for a collection purpose, within what they view overall as a particular fashion thinking methodology. The question of how the collection might work as a design tool is addressed within a larger study on fashion design practice (Ræbild, 2015). That case study comprises five companies of varying type and scale that design between 2 and 12 collections per year within a linear structure. It proposes a framework for collection building consisting of 11 interlinked parameters (represented in section 5, S590

Rethinking the Fashion Collection as a Design Strategic Tool in a Circular Economy Table 1 below). The larger study thus offers insights into the concrete elements that fashion designers, working in the context of a linear business model, take into consideration, when they strategize and design collections. 3. Methodology The case on which this paper builds is the Danish company Vigga, which offers a subscription service for baby clothing. The company was founded in 2014 and entered the market in 2015 with the explicit purpose to contribute to a sustainable development in the garment sector for children s clothing through longevity and eco-certified materials. The core data in the paper derives from a 60-minute semi-structured interview (Kvale & Brinkmann 2009) conducted in November 2016 with one of the founders of the company. It took place at Vigga s premises located in the Copenhagen area in Denmark. Previously we had collaborated with the company over a two-year period studying and prototyping materials for longevity and conducting user studies to further understand the product service system and aesthetic preferences in terms of garments and materials in a circular system (Riisberg & Petersen 2017 and Ravnløkke & Bang 2016). The interview guideline comprised questions that centred on how Vigga s designs are developed, how its garment range is structured, and how the company decides on the different subscription packages. The purpose was to clarify overall design parameters and strategic considerations in its practice. The interview data on the design and collection practice within a circular business model was analysed against design parameters pertaining to the linear and seasonally tied collection building practice in order to explore similarities and differences between the two. We have deliberately refrained from using the framework parameters in the interview guideline. This decision was made in order to let the case participant answer based on the company s own practice perspective and thus prevent a particular direction in the answers. To support the comparative analysis, we have used tables and manual colour coding. The focus has been on contextual meaning as advocated by Schembri & Sandberg (2011), as opposed to using a computational approach to search for particular words. 4. Collection Building in a Circular Business Model There are several challenges connected to designing and maintaining a collection that spans over a relatively long period of time compared to linear fashion collections. In a traditional linear fashion system each collection will be replaced by a new collection following a temporal loop that often follows the seasons. In a product service system based on subscription each item is expected to be used by different subscribers for a certain, longer period of time. In the case of Vigga the active period of each item is estimated to be 82 weeks. The Vigga collection spans approximately 2.5 years. The smallest size, Newborn, as shown in Figure 1, comes in one variation common for boys and for girls. There are 7 sizes following the Newborn size, and each size comes in two series for boys and two series for girls, i.e. a total of 29 packages. Each package contains between 15 and 20 items, depending on size, covering the basic baby wardrobe. Each size is estimated to be in the subscriber s possession from one to six months depending on the child s age and how fast the child grows. Figure 2 shows an example of different sizes. According to Peter Svensson, Co-Founder and Chief Customer Officer, this means that the customers have to adapt to the garments in a different way than in the linear fashion system where you basically buy a new item to replace or supplement your wardrobe. Thus, a crucial design challenge for Vigga is that the S591

ULLA RÆBILD, ANNE LOUISE BANG renewal and maintenance of the collection is slow and fluent, since the items are replaced stepwise as they are worn out. This puts a lot of pressure on the design of the total collection as well as renewal and adjustment of the series. Figure 1. The Newborn collection. Courtesy of Vigga. Another big challenge for the company is to adapt to the seasons and at the same time secure that each item is used for 82 weeks. Due to the Danish weather with a significant seasonal difference it is necessary to vary the collections over a year. At present the content of each package is adjusted in April and October. The combination of garments in each package is essential. Since the start in 2015 the company has added extra product lines to the service, among them a package with basic wool wear and supplementary outerwear. This is another way to add a seasonal touch to the collection. According to Peter Svensson the company is continually focusing on developing the brand and additional choices for the basic collections are one direction, for example the option of party wear. In the long run the company plans to offer a level of package customization that allows the subscribers to mix and match across the items responding to individual needs and aesthetic preferences. Lately Vigga has expanded the concept of catering to changing needs due to physical growth by adding a line of maternity wear. S592

Rethinking the Fashion Collection as a Design Strategic Tool in a Circular Economy Figure 2. A selection of styles showing three different sizes. Courtesy of Vigga. The importance of design aesthetics and design choices was emphasized several times during the interview. For example, the choice of style, colours and materials are as important as in the linear fashion system, since the design profile and the concept is the entrance point for many subscribers. It is important to define the concept and brand it in a way that attracts the subscribers. Interestingly, this also means that there may be some potential subscribers that are attracted by the concept but choose not to subscribe due to the aesthetics. The design of a linear fashion collection is highly influenced by trend and prevailing style, colour and shape, whereas the Vigga collection is more focused on enhancing product longevity through the design. However, the company has a certain style when it comes to colours, patterns and materials, cut and details. Furthermore, it is crucial that each style functions as a part of a series (the packages). Initially the company emphasized details and variations both within and across the sizes. This resulted in a highly complex range of products that turned out to be difficult to maintain. For example, some details were worn out or damaged long before the estimated 82 weeks of use. Therefore, a set of durable and wear-resistant details that secure longevity in wear and maintenance were developed. Furthermore, customer feedback showed a wish for some repetition of design elements across the sizes, e.g. cut, shape, details, patterns, and colours. However, Peter Svensson underscored the importance of designing for flexibility in sizes and fit (multiple consecutive users). In the actual collections there has been an emphasis on recognition between the series and at the same time creating universes that fit the actual size and thereby the age of the children. There is also an increased focus on solutions that fit many body types. This means that the children can use the same style and not depend on narrowness, length etc. Sustainability is one of the key parameters in the Vigga service, which has a GOTS certification (Global Organic Textile Standard) ensuring that 95% of the fabric fibres are certified organic. This standard is often referred to as the highest standard within sustainable textiles. When working with a collection that has a presumed lifetime of 82 weeks and are meant to be used by many different users, mechanical wear also plays an important role in the choice of materials. Vigga continuously seeks to develop design solutions that counteract mechanical wear by analysing wear and tear in returned items. Peter Svensson mentioned potential future initiatives, such as design for repair and disassembly as parameters worth considering on a more formalised level. Refinement of the circular business model system is dependent on feedback. Vigga gains insights from feedback from three different sources: Firstly, from its subscribers. Vigga has a very active user S593

ULLA RÆBILD, ANNE LOUISE BANG community, and feedback is obtained through the company s Facebook page. Here the company poses questions to its users on specific issues regarding the design, but it also feeds off the questions that the customers pose to the company. Furthermore Vigga holds workshops and events to gain insight into user experiences and preferences from subscribers as well as potential customers. Secondly, feedback from manufacturers is crucial. The materials suppliers are partners rather than traditional suppliers. They are involved in the development and testing of the materials. The importance of sharing values and goals is stressed, and hence the manufacturers enter into a collaborative community centred on knowledge sharing as opposed to a traditional linear supply chain. Finally, the garments themselves provide feedback when they are returned for washing and maintenance. The wear, tear and abrasion in returned garments is scrutinized and considered to be crucial information. Which part of the garment is usually ruined, which part has a good durability etc. Altogether the feedback and insight enables Vigga to conduct continuous development and refinement. The question is whether designing and maintaining a garment collection in a circular system shares some similarities with designing and developing collections in the linear fashion system. Furthermore, it is important to know whether there are additional parameters worth considering when designing for longevity with a sustainable mind-set. In the following section we analyse the case study looking at design practice in a circular system comparing it to a framework based on design practices in a linear system. 5. Comparing Circular Practices to Linear Parameters In this section, we have placed tentative findings identified in the data in a table (Table 1). The left column lists the linear collection parameters as defined by Ræbild in her larger study (2015) referenced above. The right column lists circular design practice examples that refer to the same parameters. Table 1. Linear collection parameters compared to a circular practice. Linear Collection Parameters (Ræbild, 2015) 1. Inner to outer To grade styles in collection with regard to proximity to body 2. Cool to warm To grade styles in collection with regard to temperature: a. material properties b. shifting seasons 3. Basic to complex To grade styles in collection with regard to level of design complexity 4. Circular Practice Examples (Vigga case ) The collection is similarly graded from the body and out, but in this case outerwear is an optional add-on choice. Temperature is regulated through cotton garments that can be layered and supplemented with seasonal add-ons, which can be either a material, say wool, or a garment type, say outerwear. The collection is made up of relatively classic and basic design that is interpreted in the current zeitgeist. The right balance between aesthetic longevity and in the moment relevance play a big role. Colour range To define colour range with regard to balance between newness & continuity Colour range is continuously developed in an organic process in which company aesthetics, user preferences and the longevity S594

Rethinking the Fashion Collection as a Design Strategic Tool in a Circular Economy within company expression 5. Material range To strategize material range with regard to: a. balance between newness & continuity b. material properties & expressions 6. Price range To negotiate parameters in every style within the collection during the design process based on a boundary price grid 7. Style role To define the types of garments to be included and the role of each individual style within the overall collection 8. Temporal role To define lifespan of each garment design: e.g. short trend-based, special ad hoc delivery, carry over between 1-3 collections or a stable basic. 9. Material groups To organise design & production processes around larger material groups: e.g. knits, heavy woven, denim. 10. Performative groups To develop garment styles in accordance with various strategic needs, such as e.g. editorial, show, collaboration as well as with regard to garment groups and types of fit. 11. Feedback loops To strategize and carry out information feedback loops from e.g. shops, buyers, sellers, users and manufacturers to implement in the next design process of new garments perspective are weighed against each other. The material range is built with a focus on longevity, i.e. a choice towards classic materials of high quality and durability. Say, good cotton quality that can stand heavy treatment in the homes. Furthermore the materials must be Eco certified (GOTS). Also, focus is on materials that have flexibility and form stability (of shape). This issue is not specifically addressed in the data. The packages are set at a specific price level that reflects the price range. Primary focus is on basic garments, where all items in the collection cater to specific basic wardrobe needs. Each style has to fit into a package solution and thus has a particular role in the specific package which must be easily understandable to the user. Additional style roles are developed as optional add-ons such as outerwear. All styles are developed from a longevity perspective with an overall fluent temporal loop within the same universe/style. Styles are replaced with new styles when the old ones are worn out. Design elements can carry over between styles and sizes (e.g. closure details), thus there is a strategic temporal use of design features for user recognition. It must be possible to mix all styles, while at the same time there is an attempt to vary the collections according to the seasons. There are two main material groups: Cotton for basic packages. Wool for add-on choice. It is basically knitwear. Weave and print is used to a lesser degree. Singular strategic focus: To develop garments for longevity, circulation and re-use. Sub-groups pertaining to the 29 different subscription packages; newborn, boy, girl x age groups. Sub-groups pertaining to add-on options. Multiple strategic feedback loops, e.g. material tests, user surveys, user workshops, social media communities etc. Feedback information is also gained from studying the garments themselves, in the constant flow between company and user. All feedback implemented in the development of the design. High focus on preventing the customer from having to face the same error several times. Tight collaboration with suppliers sharing the same values in order to prevent errors and secure quality. S595

ULLA RÆBILD, ANNE LOUISE BANG From the above comparison (Table 1) it can be argued that the collection parameters used in the linear fashion system are similarly relevant within a practice focused on circularity (as opposed to linearity) and product longevity (as opposed to product obsolescence). Yet, the parameters are applied in different ways in order to cater to the circularity, product longevity and re-sale aspects central to the business model. This issue will be addressed in the following section along with a number of new emerging parameters that seem unique to the circular design and collection practice. 6. A Guideline for Circular Collection Building An important part of the overall circular design strategy is the development of a number of systems that differ from the season-based and linear systems. The first one is a product service system (rather than a product system) that enables easy identification of the right product, easy access, easy use, easy maintenance and easy replacement of garment packages for users. Secondly, the practical design work is highly dependent on feedback from different stakeholders in a two-way and interactive format to support the refinement of existing design (rather than a one-way system to support sale of new design) in other words, a system of different feedback loops, where users, items and manufacturers impact the design. Lastly, the concept of the collection is visibly present and applied in the circular design practice, but the collection represents a new type of collection system thinking that involves long-term temporal planning and, in this case, a grouping of garments in specific age and gender packages. It is a system that defines garments within groups of basic wardrobe needs supplemented with individually chosen add-ons. Hence, overall the service system, the user-interaction platforms and the garments must be designed as a whole. Temporal planning is also necessary in the linear model, in the sense that it is a logistical and designerly challenge to develop and launch consecutive collections and/or garments at a high speed. The difference lies in the contrasting approaches to how the temporal aspect can be applied as a strategy, namely to aim for longevity or the opposite fast product replacement. That said, many groups within the fashion industry now do not necessarily agree with the concept of fast fashion, and durable products and good quality is not exclusively an aim within sustainability focused companies. Regarding materials, the choice of range seems as vital in the circular system as in the linear. Vigga has some specific material properties on which the company s choices are based (e.g. flexibility and certification), but such specifics can generally differ, also within the linear system. The biggest difference here is that: A. The materials must all be easy to maintain for the user in the daily caretaking (not always a criterion in the linear system), as well as on return, when they must be cleaned by the company before they are sent out again (not a criterion in the linear system). B. The range of materials is limited, and changes in the range happens slowly (this is not a predominant issue in the linear system, as focus is on newness). A number of parameters that exceeded the existing linear one emerged from the data (Table 2). For this particular case (Vigga) they represent important issues, but the level of implementation differs, from highly embedded, such as e.g. flexibility and durability, to aims for the future, such as e.g. design for disassembly and repair. S596

Rethinking the Fashion Collection as a Design Strategic Tool in a Circular Economy Table 2. New emerging parameters for strategic collection building within a circular system Parameter 1. Flexibility in fit and function Design for high level of flexibility in both function and fit to secure the highest degree of user satisfaction and to reduce the number of overall styles in the collection. 2. Technical durability Address the challenge of mechanical wear while in the user s possession through material choice and garment design. 3. Logistics vs. user preferences Balance logistical challenges with user preferences by analysing different impacts regarding sustainability. Design and develop the service in parallel with the products. 4. Package range Continued development of the product service system and the package collections. 5. Design for repair Future goal: to investigate how to design for repair. 6. Design for disassembly Future goal: to investigate how to design for disassembly, recycling and re-design. 7. Implications of Guideline Discussion Even though the parameters for designing fashion collections in the linear fashion system can be used as a guideline when designing in a circular product service system there are specific design challenges as exemplified in the above analysis. With this in mind it seems especially relevant and necessary to discuss designing for longevity and the necessary interaction with stakeholders (e.g. users and suppliers) in a circular system. We argue that the parameters above (the existing as well as the newly identified parameters) may serve as a tentative guideline for designers embarking on the journey of designing for sustainability. In addition we wish to emphasize the following design challenges in designing for sustainability in a circular product service system: Firstly, there is a need for thorough interaction with the customers in order to gain as much knowledge as possible for further development of the collection. It is crucial to develop ways to engage users and interactive meeting spaces for exchange of knowledge when designing for longevity. Secondly, there is an increased need for a close and trust-based collaboration between design companies and manufacturers. Manufacturers, moving from a linear supply chain thinking towards a circular model, can benefit from being innovation partners rather than merely suppliers. Design company and manufacturer may share the same goals and values to a higher degree than in a linear system thinking. Therefore the development regarding design for repair and disassembly may well be situated here and build on knowledge developed within other sectors. A good example is the technology sector, for example the phone company Fairphone (fairphone.com). They offer a modular phone design and spare parts which make it easy for anyone to make repairs. Thirdly, there is an increasing need for fashion companies to see fashion design as a process of gradual refinement rather than replacement. Besides, in terms of a reduction in the sustainable footprint, there is also a huge market potential in the circular models. There are numerous target groups and aesthetic positions to choose from that further the development of a circular economy in fashion and textiles. S597

ULLA RÆBILD, ANNE LOUISE BANG 8. Conclusion In the beginning of the paper we set out to investigate how the collection, as a particular design framework, might be reconfigured as a strategic driver for garment longevity furthering sustainable fashion design. We have used the case of Vigga to argue that designing garment collections for a circular product service system includes many similarities with traditional collection building. Furthermore, we identified a set of additional parameters relevant to consider when designing for a garment collection in a circular product service system. This paper has focused on a study of a subscription service for baby clothing; there may be other differences within other target groups or garment groups. However, we suggest that this paper may serve as a starting point for discussions of key questions regarding how to design the fashion collection in a circular product service system; how to transfer good practices to other enterprises and also to what extent the designer exerts strategic influence. In order to further generate and strengthen the knowledge about designing fashion collections for circular systems it will be highly relevant to add cases to this example. References Botsman, R., Rogers, R. (2011) What's Mine Is Yours: The Rise of Collaborative Consumption. London: Collins. Fletcher, K., Grose, L. (2012) Fashion & Sustainability Design for Change. London: Laurence King publishing. Fletcher, K., Tham, M. (2015)(Eds.) Routledge Handbook of Sustainability and Fashion. New York: Routledge. Gardetti, M.Á., Torres, A.L., (2013)(Eds.) Sustainability in Fashion and Textiles: Values, Design, Production and Consumption. Sheffield: Greenleaf Publishing. GOTS, (2016). Retrieved from http://global-standard. org/en/the-standard/general-description.html [Accessed 18 December 2016] Kvale, S., Brinkmann, S. (2009) InterView. København: Hans Reitzels Forlag. Lacy, P., Rutquist, J. (2015) Waste to Wealth The Circular Economy Advantage. UK: Palgrave Macmillan. Le Pechoux, B., Little, T. J., Istook, C. L. (2001) Innovation Management in Creating New Fashion. In Hines, T., Bruce, M. (Eds) 2001, Fashion Marketing: Contemporary Issues, Chapter 8, pp. 136-164. Nixon, N. W., Blakley, J. (2012) Fashion Thinking: Towards an Actionable Methodology. In Fashion Practice, Volume 4, Issue 2, pp. 153-176. Berg. Petersen, T. B., & Riisberg, V. (2017, forthcoming). Cultivating Usership? Developing a circular system for the acquisition and use of baby clothing. Fashion Practise. The Journal of Design, Creative Process & the Fashion Industry. Taylor & Francis. Ravnløkke, L. & Bang, A. (2016). The Body Stocking: Design Aesthetics and Functionality as Means for Sustainable Fashion and Textiles. In: Desmet, P., Fokkinga, S., Ludden, G., Cila, N., & Van Zuthen, H. (2016) (Eds.) Celebration & Contemplation: Proceedings of the Tenth International Conference on Design and Emotion, Amsterdam, September 27-30, 2016. Amsterdam: The Design & Emotion Society. Renfrew, C., Renfrew, E. (2016) Developing a Collection. In Basics Fashion Design 04. UK: AVA Publishing. Ræbild, U. (2015) Uncovering Fashion Design Method Practise the Influence of Body, Time and Collection. Ph.d. dissertation. Designskolen Kolding and Teko Via University College. Denmark S598

Rethinking the Fashion Collection as a Design Strategic Tool in a Circular Economy Schembri, S., Sandberg, J. (2011) The Experiential Meaning of Service Quality. In Marketing Theory, 11 (2) pp. 165-186. Sage. Sinha, P. (2002) Creativity in Fashion. In Journal of Textile and Apparel, Technology and Management. Volume 2. Issue IV, Fall 2002. Vigga A/S. www.vigga.us. [accessed 18 December 2016] About the Authors: Ulla Ræbild is an Assistant Professor in Fashion, Method & Sustainability at Design School Kolding, Denmark. She earned her PhD degree in fashion design methodology in 2015 and has since pursued research and development at the intersection of fashion design practise, design education and sustainability. Anne Louise Bang is an Associate Professor in Textiles, Co-Design and Sustainability at Design School Kolding, Denmark. She earned her PhD degree in applied textiles in 2011 and has since pursued research at the intersection of textiles, dialogue tools and sustainability. Acknowledgements: We would like to thank Vigga A/S for the inspiring collaboration that started in 2014 funded by Green Business Development/The Danish Business Authority. S599